1964 (at Ball State)

Winners Bracket

Earlham def. Indiana Inst. of Tech. 2-0 (15-9, 15-3)
Ball State def. George Williams 2-1 (14-6, 17-15, 15-6)
Ohio State def. Earlham 3-0 (15-10, 18-16)
Ball State def. Ohio State 2-0 (15-6, 15-10)

Losers Bracket
George Williams def. Indiana Inst. of Tech. 2-0 (15-5, 15-9)
George Williams def. Earlham 2-1 (11-15, 15-4, 15-6)
George Williams def. Ohio State 2-0 (15-6, 15-13)

Championship
Ball State def. George Williams 2-0 (15-10, 15-10)